Let’s Be Real: Pitbulls vs. Society
For many years, pitbulls have been a hot button issue for law enforcement, animal activists, and pet owners alike. There is an almost constant tension between those who believe that pitbulls are more violent than other breeds of dog, and those that do not. Many people, especially those in or having ties to law enforcement, tend to lean on the side of viewing any dog that resembles a pitbull, including mutts and mixed breeds, as violent and dangerous towards everything and everyone.
Personally, I don’t believe that pit bulls are any more or less dangerous as any other breed of dog. In fact, I feel like they are some of the kindest, most trustworthy dogs out there.
What makes us demonize and incriminate pit bulls? I think the answer lies with a general fear that all pet owners, new and experienced, have when it comes to looking at a dog. It’s the standard to walk by the pitbulls and ignore them as they sit alone and isolated in the shops, pounds, and rescues. However, that shouldn’t be the case in my mind. There lies plenty of fear behind any type of pet, especially dogs, and even more so with the hundreds of breeds that exist.
For example, why should I fear for my life around a pitbull when the golden retriever or border collie or chihuahua sitting twenty feet away has the exact same power and potential to carry out the same acts of aggression and violence that pitbull are known for? There are no reasonable explanations as to why people could choose breeds apart from the pitbull and seemingly be immune from any sort of violence.
It’s also important to mention that a pitbull is not a breed, but instead, a general term used to class breeds of dogs with similar traits and characteristics commonly referred to as pitbulls.
Some of these breeds include the American Staffordshire Bull Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier, American Bully, and other bull terrier breeds. Bulldog, Cane Corso, Dogo Argentino, and Bullmastiff are also breeds commonly looped into this classification.
Now, the heart of the issue behind the immense hatred toward pitbulls is their actions towards people and other dogs. More specifically, the interactions among families with infants and young children. Yes, there have been attacks, some fatal, that have involved pitbulls. Nevertheless, all pitbulls should not be shamed and in most cases, taken away or euthanized, just because of previous incidents that have happened.
The stereotype is that pitbulls are dangerous around children and other dogs, and because of that, a lot of law enforcement offices will contact homeowners or landlords and threaten to confiscate the dog and push jail time and fines for owners who do not give up their pitbulls. It has come to a point where I question the priorities that police have over certain animals. There have been numerous cases where pitbulls have been shot and killed while protecting their owners or simply just being on site during police action. Yes, police will intentionally shoot to kill a pitbull just because of the previous cases they have been informed.
So what could police officers do to change their ways about pitbulls? It’s simple: use them. If police truly believe that all pitbulls are violent, then why not adopt or rescue them and train them to become police and drug dogs? It would certainly bring more good to the face of the name, as well as prove that pitbulls are loyal companions that are great to keep around and rely on.
Another hard point that I have argued is that all pitbulls are violent. No, they are not. With the right amounts of training and affection, no pitbull is violent. Society has this image in their minds that pitbulls are untrainable, they are super violent, and they cannot be trusted around families. That’s wrong. In fact, pitbulls are widely known to be extremely loyal to their owners and their families. They will defend their family, even if it means they are put in harm’s way, such is the case for intruders and police officers attempting to seize them.
At the end of the day, pitbulls can be violent. But so can any dog. It’s important that we as people understand that, and also to realize that we should not demonize these loyal, kind, and trustworthy animals. They are not monsters. We are not monsters. There is room for change, and that is what we should see, not violence and hate.
My name is Connor Gority, or CG if you know me better, and I’m a junior at Tyrone High School. If you’ve ever been to Tyrone or live in the area and...
Lisa • Feb 10, 2021 at 7:02 pm
I mean I could train a person to be a terrorist, the only reason is that they are somehow trainable, no matter it’s because some religion they are in or what. And usually you would think people are probably mentally ill if they are trained to kill others.
If you translate this into dog personality, this means they are obedience. The only reason you could train a pitbull into a fighting dog is because they let you to. During the process you probably drive the dog crazy so it became a vicious monster.
You also have to be a giant asshole to train a healthy dog into this, and I happened to be not an asshole, so instead I trained my pitbull to stay calm when a one year old poked her finger into my dog’s eyes.
There aren’t misteries in pitbulls, they can feel pain and they don’t have locked jaws. Just like there aren’t misteries in people. You are probably going to think terrorists are a kind of crazy people, but it would be stupid to think they have superpower and will turn into Hulk in any second.
J Bill • Dec 1, 2020 at 12:53 pm
Pit bulls are the sweetest animals on the planet. And NO. THEY DID NOT EARN THEIR REPUTATION. Pit bulls are only agressive because their owners abuse them. I have a pit bull myself. I read a story saying that there was a pit bull who died saving his family from a venomous snake. He was willing to sacrifice his own life as a 9 month old pitbull to save his owners. I wouldnt call that worthy of an agressive reputation. And I know whoever is reading this wouldnt either.
Guillermo Gomez • Nov 16, 2020 at 7:49 am
I m a pitbull owner of 3 fur babies they are sweet lovable dogs it’s how you raise them nothing wrong with the breed but there a lot of stupid people out there that think otherwise
Nolan Gonzalez • Nov 15, 2020 at 6:18 pm
Reading these comments is like trying to mop in the ocean. Zero actual knowledge of pits just full of people who live for sonic, TGIF, and Buffalo Wild Wings these adults are like kids stating nothing but bs “THESE DOGS HAVE EARNED THEIR REPUTATIONS” well no shi*t d*psh*t when people use these dogs and breed them to fight of course you simple minded kids are gonna keep that label on them. Pathetic
Nomadi287 • Nov 14, 2020 at 8:15 am
If you hate pitbulls because of the reputation then i just assume you hate everyone in the middle east too.
Ric Butner • Nov 13, 2020 at 2:42 pm
I have had a female pit for 7 years now. She is the smartest one in my family. Hell she even knows what I am spelling when I spell cookie or bye bye. She love hugs and puts both her paws around your neck and presses her head up against you. The only thing she is very protective. I can hit myself on my hand and say owe and she starts growing and barking until I tell her that I am ok. My wife will play with her and she sounds and look like she is going to tear my wife up. She will bite her hands or arm but never really clamp down no marks what so ever. My Son is Autistic and he loves her and they get along great. If he is gone she waits by the door till he gets home. The only down side of having her around is I can’t kiss or hug my wife or even sit by her. Ruby wants the attention and has to sit between us. But never know aggression.But I pity the person who tries to cause any of my family harm. The best breed of dog we could have in the family.
Cat Girl • Sep 25, 2020 at 10:52 am
I don’t know why pit bull owners use the “any dog can be aggressive” as if a Chihuahua is going to be able to rip your face off. Pitbulls have been known to be unpredictable, even with no history of abuse. They were breed for fighting after all. People, especially children and other pets, aren’t going to tippy toe around your dog just because it had a bad history and it could snap at any trigger.
Tony Erasmus • Sep 23, 2020 at 12:39 pm
We resently moved into a complex in Rustenburg with our beautiful two pitbulls,the neighbour next door went to the housing agent snd complained about the two pitbulls (one male one female)her arguement was she is scared of them and for her children now they cant play in the street.But in the mean time when i confronted her she tells me there are break ins in the complex and she doesnt really know this dog bread but still we had to find a home for them or sit in the street now i ask with tears in my eyes if you dont know the bread why go out your way to make life difficult for them we seriously miss our babies people get educated about pitbulls they are to us the best (dam a siamese cat killed its owner once)really give pitbulls a break i will never have another animal in my house again Love Pitbulls
Chris • Sep 23, 2020 at 6:23 am
I have had pit bulls 4 the last 35 years and i will tell u they are the most loving n loyal dog u could ever have. Sure, u can make them mean, but u can make ANY dog mean, any dog. U want a dog 2 protect u , ur family n property, right? These dogs r great 4 that n great with family. They r loving dogs, but in the wrong hands, yes could be dangerous. But like any dog, u treat him right, give him love, i promise u, he will give it all back n then some. Best dog u could EVER have great with kids 2, just give them love
Shey • Sep 22, 2020 at 10:53 pm
My girl is a pit mix and she is the sweetest sensitive soul. She disobeyed a command and got yelled at. She immediately put herself to bed.
While I do believe that reputations are earned, it comes down to training and proper socialization. It should be said, that this breed must be handled properly, cause my goodness, when done right what a wonderful dog breed. My pit loves kids, others dogs and cats. As responsible dog owners, we should take great pride in setting our dogs up for success. It’s not the breed, it comes down to socialization and the owners.
Carl Koch • Sep 22, 2020 at 7:57 pm
My wife and I are parents to a 120 pound Presa Canario. He is routinely mistaken for a pit bull. Side by side the difference is noticeable. He looks intimidating but is a mellow fellow unless provoked. We drove from Dallas to Atlanta to rescue him. We have never looked back. We would do it again. To help with the public we trained him to perform mobility assist functions and had him certified as a service dog. He also helps me with anxiety attacks. He is crazy protective of mommy and daddy. People confuse his protective nature with aggression. There is a big difference. He is never off lead when out of our house. He sleeps with me every night.
Amiee • Sep 22, 2020 at 5:50 pm
I agree 100 percent a dog is only as good or bad as its owner. If u raise a pitbull as I have plenty of times with love n kindness u will have the best dog ever. U n ur family will always b protected n u will always have a great friend. All 3 of my kids have been raised around all types of dogs n hands down I would always choose a pitbull. They love kids, r so funny n as I said will protect who it loves. Really isn’t that wut u want ur dog to do? To b ur best friend n to protect u n urs from any harm?
Laura Lee Zank • Sep 22, 2020 at 11:11 am
A dog is only as good or bad as its owner, if you treat it bad you will get a bad response but if you are kind an loving you will have the most loving friend you will ever have
sandra mcdade • Aug 15, 2020 at 5:43 pm
My piit bull is the most sweetest, loving, loyal dog I have ever had in my life. He doesn’t have a mean none in his body. He runs and plays with the chickens in the yard and big Tom pussy cat smacks him and he goes running lol. He has never hurt or killed anyone or anything JUST THE WAY HE LAYS BESIDE ME AT NIGHT AND TAKES ONE ARM AND PUTS OVER ME SHOWs his love for me and his caring nature!
Iceis • Aug 11, 2020 at 8:04 am
I disagree. Pit bulls are so much more dangerous than any of the dog breeds mentioned. I was mauled by one a few months ago. Deep puncture wounds bloody bruises. It was unprovoked I was walking home. I now suffer PTSD bad. They all should be banned. They are unpredictable and have it in them to kill / fight to the death regardless how its cared for. Beware. I warned you.
Gerda Byrd • Aug 4, 2020 at 9:12 am
I have a precious smart loyal pitting, I love him with all my heart. Get off the myths about those beautiful loyal funny animals. Most of you are uneducated running your stupid mouths. Shut up and get yourselves a real dog, a pitti.
Cynthia • Jul 31, 2020 at 11:31 am
Before anyone gets a dog they should study the breed or mix of breeds in the dog to deside if that particular breed or dog is right for you and your family. 90% of bull dog breeds are not bad. That is misinformation. They get a bad rap from HUMANS fighting them which is totally inhumane!!!! And they don’t just fight pitbulls, they fight all different breeds of dogs. It is wrong on so many levels. Anyway, you want a good dog for protection any bull dog breed would be great. Bullmastiff’s in my opinion are the best! I have owned 3. They were my sweet babies. They all lived to be old. The very first one I had, she lived the longest. 15 years❤ I miss her as I do all of them. Everyday. So basically my opinion is…. Dont just get a dog because it looks cool or some ridiculous reason such as that. Get one that you for sure want. That suits you and your family.
Leanne Cook • Jul 26, 2020 at 12:46 am
The Bull breed dogs are some of the kindest dogs I’ve met. Yes, there have been incedents, but they were nearly all by abused, untrained, or badly socialized dogs. The PitBull scored 2nd in the temperament test done on all berrds by the ASPCA! One of the main problems is the media loves to report the damage done by Pittys because it sells. They will go so far as to call it a Pit, even when it’s a Lab or many other large breeds! The most aggressive breeds are the Chihuahua, the Jack Russel and the Daschund!
My girl is not a purebred Pit, but she is the kindest soul you could ever meet. She loves everything alive. Bunnys, Cats, other dogs, chickens crawl on her and she runs from the ducks. She even rescued a baby Vole and dropped it at a gal she had just met’s feet and cried for her to save it. It came out of her mouth dry and not a hair out of place… this is not a mean dog, and should not be punished as one! I’ve personally never met a mean Pitty!
Joe Weber • Mar 1, 2020 at 6:42 pm
I have a pit bull and he’s one of the most loving and loyal dogs I’ve ever had.
Linda Christian • Feb 26, 2020 at 10:12 am
I read a lot about pit bulldogs, 90% are bad. They. May have been breed way back to fighr,kill etc. But so were humans. Let’s not forget Cane and Able. Where’d this all come about? I’m sure Adam and Eve didn’t teach them to kill. I’ve seen a lot of other breeds of dogs attack. Some because a HUMAN was harassing it, or trying to take it’s baby or food. I have 3 pits, they snap at. Each other on occasion, but when it comes to mama (me) they are the most loving dogs I’ve ever had. I also have a lab and a border collie. The border collie , who is the. Smalkezt, makes the rest step around. She’s the boss. I love them all.
Mary Haupt • Dec 28, 2019 at 9:43 am
I have an American Pitt Bull Terrier. We took her in after my daughter’s landlord made her get rid of the 5mo. old pup. Wembley is now 10. She is very gentle with kids. The younger the kid the more gentle she is. She does bark and growl at people entering our property but when we are ok with the person she runs to get her ball and wants to play.. she knows the boundaries of our property and usually stays in the yard. She gets excited when she sees a stroller going down the street and will race to. greet the people. They are usually. nervous till I catch up with the dog, scold her and take her inside. When she hears the kids across the street crying Wembley looks worried and whines. I have to tell her it’s ok. On neutral ground she’s good with other dogs. At home she will sometimes be aggressive when other dogs go down the street but when that happens I scold her and take her inside. That’s our standard punishment. She gets put on the love seat and told she’s bad and has to stay. She looks pretty pathetic till we let her get up while still telling her she was bad. Overall she’s very sweet and much better with young kids than the Jack Russell Terrier mix we had years before we got Wembley. She loves kids.
Pitbull lover • Dec 26, 2019 at 1:23 pm
Very true. Pitbulls have been involved in some bad incidents. But, most of those animals were in fact untrained or trained for protection/aggressiveness. So, the press and other factors have been responsible for this negative attitude. I personally believe if you have a dog of any breed, it could be made vicious and be trained to harm. I have a Red Nose pit mix…..the most loving creature anyone could ever want.
Manx • Dec 20, 2018 at 8:23 am
I love animals of all kinds, but I recognize the danger in each of them, and this creature, despite its beauty, is dangerous. You say that it has a reputation for being dangerous and that it is untrue. But keep in mind, a reputation is not given, it’s earned,
coolbeans • Dec 10, 2018 at 11:11 am
i love pitbulls
Mr. Epic Miles • Dec 10, 2018 at 10:10 am
Let’s be real, Pitbulls aren’t seen as aggressive and mean for no reason. They’ve earned that reputation.
legitimate Indian • Dec 7, 2018 at 12:00 pm
Pit Bulls breeds descend from dog breeds that were bred for fighting. Their origin comes from Bull-baiting and Bear-baiting. In other words, blood sports. And when this was made illegal people simply used Pit bulls in fights against one another. – United Kennel Club
Studies indicate that pit bull-type dogs were involved in approximately a third of human DBRF (i.e., dog bite related fatalities) – Breeds of dogs involved in fatal human attacks in the united states between 1979 and 1998
You stated the cops should use them if they’re violent but that isn’t exactly a good argument. If someone is a psychopath should they join the military? No, that’s dangerous for everyone involved. You said a chihuahua, golden retriever, and a border collie could enact the same acts of aggression as a Pit Bull. That’s an interesting idea, seeing as of the dogs mentioned the Put Bull outweighs all of them, save for the Golden Retriever. But that’s null and void when all other breeds mentioned aren’t even in the top 20 for strongest bite force. The Pit bull takes seventh place. They have a reputation for a reason.
Pitbull • Dec 7, 2018 at 8:48 am
It’s Mr. Worldwide.